---
title: API: retrying an alert-rule create returns the rule, not a conflict
description: If a request to create an alert rule timed out and you retried it with the same Idempotency-Key, you got a 409 saying the rule already exists, because your…
canonical: https://watchfor.io/changelog/2026-11-20-api-alert-rule-create-retry-safe
---

[All updates](/changelog/page/2#2026-11-20-api-alert-rule-create-retry-safe) 🐛 Fixed API Nov 20, 2026 · v 13.5.5

# API: retrying an alert-rule create returns the rule, not a conflict

If a request to create an alert rule timed out and you retried it with the same Idempotency-Key, you got a 409 saying the rule already exists, because your first attempt had created it. A retry now replays the original 201 with the rule, like every other create in the API. A real duplicate (another request for the same metric and severity) is still a 409.

Share this update

---

Canonical page: https://watchfor.io/changelog/2026-11-20-api-alert-rule-create-retry-safe · Site guide: https://watchfor.io/llms.txt
